Is Windsurf Better Than Vs Code?

When comparing Windsurf with Visual Studio Code (VS Code), it's important to understand that Windsurf builds on VS Code's foundation but takes a decidedly different approach by integrating AI directly into the editor's core. Here's a breakdown of the differences and the trade-offs:

Enhanced AI-Driven Workflow

• Integrated Assistance: Unlike vanilla VS Code, which depends on third-party extensions like GitHub Copilot for AI suggestions, Windsurf comes with built-in AI flows. Features like Cascade let the editor pre-write changes (even saving them to disk before you approve them), which some users say helps maintain a “flow state” and provides real-time feedback on your code changes.
• Simplified, Polished UI: Many developers describe Windsurf as having a cleaner, more intuitive user interface compared to the sometimes cluttered experience in VS Code—especially when using multiple AI plugins. It's designed to minimize distractions, focusing on high-level interactions rather than overwhelming you with options.

The Trade-Offs

• Control vs. Automation: VS Code traditionally gives you manual control over which files to include in context and when to accept changes. Windsurf, in contrast, tends to “act” more on your behalf—writing changes automatically in some cases. This can be a boon for beginners or those who prefer a more guided experience, but power users who enjoy granular control might miss some of VS Code's manual precision.
• Learning Curve: Windsurf is aimed at simplicity and ease of use, making it a strong candidate for developers new to AI-enhanced coding. However, some advanced users report that they appreciate VS Code's flexibility and the ability to tailor extensions to their specific workflows.
• Price Considerations: Windsurf's pricing is competitive—starting around $15 per seat compared to some alternatives—while still offering an impressive suite of built-in AI features. For users upgrading from a plain VS Code experience, the cost and learning curve might be a small trade-off for the extra productivity gains.

Ultimately, whether Windsurf is “better” than VS Code depends on your priorities. If you value an integrated AI workflow that automates common tasks and helps maintain a coding flow, Windsurf is worth trying. However, if you prefer having complete manual control and a mature ecosystem with extensive customization options, sticking with VS Code (augmented by your favorite extensions) may still be the way to go.